A recent study conducted by UCD Michael Smurfit Graduate Business School sheds light on consumer behaviour post-product incidents, revealing an intriguing trend: brands perceived as caring and friendly receive more feedback following such incidents.

Contrary to expectations, this feedback tends to be constructive rather than vindictive, providing brands with valuable insights for improvement.

Led by Anshu Suri, Assistant Professor of Marketing at UCD Smurfit School, in collaboration with researchers from McGill University and the University of Tennessee, the study delved into the dynamics of consumer responses to product-harm incidents, particularly in the automotive industry. The findings highlight a significant correlation between brand warmth and the volume and nature of incident reports received by brands.

Increased Reports, More Constructive Feedback

Analysis of harm incident reports from car owners revealed a notable trend: a 1% increase in brand warmth corresponds to a 27% rise in the number of reports received post-incident. Moreover, this surge in reports is accompanied by a 4% increase in the proportion of feedback aimed at providing constructive solutions rather than mere complaints. This suggests that consumers perceive warm brands as approachable entities genuinely interested in resolving issues.

The study underscores the importance of cultivating a warm brand personality, achieved through consistent displays of responsibility and care, such as investment in societal and environmental initiatives. Noteworthy examples include Patagonia’s transition to a non-profit entity focused on combating climate change. Brand warmth becomes particularly pivotal in the aftermath of product-harm incidents, where consumer trust and brand reputation are at stake.

Consumer Benevolence and Satisfaction

Professor Suri suggests that consumer benevolence towards warm brands plays a crucial role in driving constructive feedback post-incidents. Consumers demonstrate a genuine concern for the brand’s well-being, motivating them to provide helpful feedback rather than resorting to complaints. Moreover, brands that acknowledge and appreciate consumers’ motives for feedback witness enhanced consumer satisfaction, highlighting the reciprocal nature of brand-consumer interactions.

The study’s findings carry significant implications for brand management strategies. Investing in the development of a warm brand personality not only fosters consumer trust and loyalty but also encourages proactive engagement from consumers during challenging times. Conversely, brands neglecting to cultivate warmth risk facing punitive actions from consumers, who may resort to complaints as a form of retribution.

Editor at The B2B Marketer | Website | + posts

The B2B Marketer, the online destination for B2B marketing professionals seeking valuable insights, trends, and resources to drive their marketing strategies and achieve business success.